Solar, Gas, and Electric: 4 Points of Comparison
The second article in a two-part series on pool heating
In our last article on pool heating options, we looked at the basic differences between pool heating options: solar, gas, or electric. For wintertime swimmers, gas or electric are essentially a must. For the client who simply wants an extended season, the solar pool heating option is more cost effective. If you find yourself somewhere in-between on these issues, let’s get into the detailed differences on four different points of comparison: practicality, cost, performance, and environmental impact.
Solar vs. Traditional – Practicality
One of your main considerations is the practicality of the heating system you chose. Think about your local climate and how often you use or want to use your pool. Because they rely on the sun’s power, solar systems work best in sunny regions, while traditional electric and gas heaters can be used in any weather and are still effective in winter. The most apparent difference between gas and electric heaters is that they use different power sources. You may want to consider the practicality of one power source over the other on your specific property. For example, if you receive gas from a delivery service, a gas heater will just lead to more deliveries.
Solar vs. Traditional – Cost Comparison
The initial installation costs for solar systems like Heliocol can have higher upfront costs compared to gas and electric heaters. However, operational costs for solar systems are essentially zero, while gas and electric heaters have significant monthly utility cost. Traditional heaters often require regular maintenance and part replacements, while Heliocol systems need minimal maintenance or parts replacement over their lifetime.
Solar vs. Traditional – Performance and Usability
When it comes to performance, gas heaters are ideal for quick heating on-demand. Electric systems (which are usually based on heat pump technology) and solar systems like Heliocol are slower to raise temperatures. The advantage to Heliocol pool temperature regulation, however, is that the solar grid can also act as a pool cooling system! When summer nighttime temperatures fall, the water pump can be engaged to run hot or uncomfortably warm pool water through cool evening air. The result is a drop in pool temperature so that your water remains pleasant to swim in. Neither gas nor electric systems can offer this option.
Durability and reliability are also very important to performance. Heliocol solar systems are built to last, offering reliable performance for many years. Traditional heaters on the other hand often suffer from wear and tear, leading to potential breakdowns and higher maintenance costs.
Solar vs. Traditional – Environmental Impact
It goes without saying that the use of solar power heating relies entirely on renewable energy and that promotes sustainability. Gas and electric methods are not only less energy-efficient, but they use significant amounts of non-renewable energy which contributes to greenhouse gas emissions, impacting the environment. As mentioned in our previous article, you can minimize the electricity and carbon costs of an electrical heater with photovoltaic solar panels, but that’s an additional investment. If the environmental impact of your choices is important to you, then solar powered heating is your best option.
Making the Right Pool Heating Choice
As you can see, there are a number of factors to consider when choosing a pool heating system. Besides the practicality, initial and long-term cost, performance, usability, and environmental impact factors, we recommend you review the testimonials of homeowners that use the systems you are considering. Are they pleased with their choice? What benefits do they list? What drawbacks do they mention? Most importantly, work with an experienced and reputable company that installs and helps you maintain and troubleshoot your system. Informed decisions will enhance your swimming experience.
Solar Pool Heating with Solaron
As a solar pool heating company, we of course believe that solar is the smartest choice and the Heliocol brand we offer is superior to others. The cost savings and environmental sustainability alone make solar an excellent choice for many property owners. In addition, Heliocol systems are designed for durability and require minimal maintenance, often lasting 15-20 years.
If you are considering solar pool heating, explore our website to learn more about your solar options and review the many testimonials of our clients. Solaron is pleased to answer any questions you have, and we offer onsite consultations to discuss your pool heating needs. Call us or submit an online form request today!